Cold Stone Creamery Valley Stream: Premium Ice Cream with Friendly Service
Cold Stone Creamery in Valley Stream, NY, delivers a vibrant ice cream experience with a wide selection of flavors and unique creations like the Apple Pie a La Cold Stone and Reese’s Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cup. The generous portions and custom options, including birthday cakes and smoothies, cater to diverse tastes. Friendly, attentive staff elevate the visit, creating a welcoming atmosphere despite the lack of seating. While prices skew higher, the quality and personalized service shine through, making it a go-to spot for family treats and loyal customers seeking indulgent, handcrafted ice cream delights. A true haven for ice cream lovers craving both creativity and care.
Cold Stone Creamery at a glance
- Address 750 Sunrise Hwy Ste 4105, Valley Stream, NY 11581, United States
- Phone +1 516-888-0707
- Restaurant type Ice cream shop .
- Popular for Solo dining .
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
Apple Pie a La Cold Stone
Very Vanilla Shake
Smoothie
Custom Birthday Cake
Reese's Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cup 6-Pack - Ready Now
Mineral Water
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety 4-Pack - Ready Now
Cake Batter Confetti - Ready Now
Candy
Cold Stone Creamery: Reviews & Ratings
I highly recommend this location to all. However, it is extremely pricey. Make sure to pay your employees they carry your brand. give discounts and deals, especially to loyalty customers like myself. At this point we are locked in as family. pull up.
i’ve tried their mint chocolate chip ice cream and it was pretty good, a little bit too much chocolate in my opinion but other than that it was great. nice service and reasonable prices for their sizes
Went to get ice cream. The place was crowded, but we were served quickly. Good customer service. I was able to change my order with no issue. There is no seating inside tho. Ice cream was lovely. The serving size was generous too. We visited on a Sunday.
WOW! I’ve never been in an establishment that had such friendly staff! Every time I go in, they make sure I get exactly what I want. Always happy, laughing, and such good energy. I love coming in here! They play the best music and make me feel right at home! Plus they offer so many flavors and make the perfect mix in for me every single time. Y’all gotta come here. Seriously it’s the best :)
I enjoy Cold Stone ice cream and this time in particular, staff member TK made my day! She was so professional, helpful and friendly. She ensured my ice cream was just right and I was provided with all the utensils needed. I never usually am given napkins. The service was top tier with TK and I am pleased with the exceptional service. If you're going to this Valley Stream location, you must ask for TK to receive the best service!
It's so beneficial that this location is now always open until 1am. They are always kind to me when I visit this establishment. The vibes are always on point, just like the music;). The ice cream is always stacked high and even if the ice cream is low they will get it from the back with no issues. I highly recommend this ice cream spot to all looking for a late night snack, or just a snack whenever!
Who Doesn’t Love Ice Cream! The Young Ladies Were Kind & Attentive. With A Slew Of Flavors Pretty Hard To Choose One.
I had such a great experience at Cold Stone Creamery! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a big smile and a friendly “Welcome in!” The staff here really make you feel like a valued customer, and they were so quick with my order. Normally, this place is packed (and with good reason), but they’re pros at moving things along without making you feel rushed. I think I was in and out in about five minutes—pretty impressive for such a popular spot! That warm, sweet smell of fresh waffle cones hits you the second you walk in, and it’s just so comforting. The place is clean, lively, and well-organized, which makes the whole experience even better. I went with my usual favorite, the Dulce de Leche ice cream with banana and graham crackers mixed in. The ice cream itself is smooth and rich, and the flavors blend perfectly—just the right balance of caramel sweetness with that fresh banana taste and a bit of crunch from the graham crackers. It’s such a satisfying combo and the perfect treat for winding down after a long day. Cold Stone always hits the spot, but the vibe and efficient service here make it stand out. If you’re looking for a quick dessert fix or just want to treat yourself to something extra tasty, I’d highly recommend stopping by. You won’t regret it!
Location
-
Cold Stone Creamery750 Sunrise Hwy Ste 4105, Valley Stream, NY 11581, United States Hotline: +1 516-888-0707
Cold Stone Creamery in Valley Stream, NY, is more than just an ice cream shop—it's a place where dessert dreams come alive. Nestled at 750 Sunrise Hwy Ste 4105, this spot offers a rich selection of handcrafted ice cream treats that cater to every craving. From the indulgent Apple Pie a La Cold Stone to the classic Very Vanilla Shake, each menu item is crafted with care and quality ingredients. Their Custom Birthday Cakes and ready-to-go options like the Reese's Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cup 6-Pack and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Variety 4-Pack bring convenience without sacrificing flavor.
What truly sets Cold Stone apart is the experience. Customers praise not only the generous serving sizes but also the attentive, friendly staff who create an inviting atmosphere filled with energy and laughter. Whether it’s the flawless mix-ins or the quick, accommodating service—even during busy times—the team ensures every visit feels special. The lively music and welcoming vibe make it a perfect spot to indulge solo or with family.
The balance between flavor and texture stands out, especially in varieties like the Mint Chocolate Chip, which strikes a satisfying harmony despite a robust chocolate presence. While some note the price point as higher than average, the quality, variety, and personalized service justify the indulgence. For those seeking a memorable ice cream experience with a touch of warmth and professionalism, Cold Stone Creamery in Valley Stream is a sweet destination that truly delivers.
Business Information
- Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- In-store shopping
- On-site services
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards